Staged Ratings Explained: Why One VA Decision Can List Several Percentages for the Same Condition

Legal Services · November, 2026

7 min read · 0 comments

Staged Ratings Explained: Why One VA Decision Can List Several Percentages for the Same Condition 7 min

A VA decision may assign different ratings for different time periods when the evidence shows a condition was more or less severe at different points. These are called staged ratings, and they allow the VA to match each period’s percentage to the symptoms documented during that period instead of applying one number to the entire claim.

Veterans in Utah and elsewhere are often surprised to open a decision letter and see the same condition rated 10% for one stretch of time and 30% for another. Understanding why that happens, and how the VA picks the dates, can help veterans decide whether the decision fits their medical history.

What Is a Staged Rating?

A staged rating is a series of percentages for one service-connected condition, each tied to a specific date range. Instead of saying a condition was 20% disabling for the whole period under review, the VA might find it was 10% disabling up to a certain date and 20% disabling after that.

The concept comes from decisions of the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims:

  • Fenderson v. West (1999) addressed appeals of an initial rating assigned when service connection is first granted. The court recognized that a veteran may be assigned separate percentage evaluations for separate periods, based on the facts found during the appeal period, and that the evaluation should reflect the condition’s recorded history rather than only its severity at a single moment.
  • Hart v. Mansfield (2007) extended that approach to claims for increased ratings. Board decisions describe Hart as holding that staged ratings are appropriate in an increased-rating claim when the factual findings show distinct time periods in which the disability had symptoms warranting different ratings.

In short, staged ratings exist so the rating can follow the condition as it changes.

How Do Staged Ratings Appear in a Decision Letter?

Staged ratings usually show up as a list of percentages for the same condition, each with its own effective date. For example, a decision might read along these lines:

  • Lumbar strain, 10% from the date the claim was received
  • Lumbar strain, 20% from the date of a later VA examination

The rating code sheet in the claims file typically shows the same information in table form. Each row reflects a period and the percentage the VA assigned for it.

Veterans sometimes read the lower percentage as a mistake or the higher percentage as a new grant. In reality, both are part of one decision describing how the VA viewed the condition over time.

Why Would the VA Split a Rating Into Different Periods?

The VA assigns staged ratings when it finds that the evidence shows significant changes in severity. Common reasons include:

  • Worsening over time, such as a joint condition that loses range of motion
  • Improvement after treatment, such as surgery or therapy that reduces symptoms
  • A temporary spike, such as a period of frequent flare-ups followed by a return to a lower baseline
  • New evidence at a certain date, such as an exam or test that first documents a higher level of severity

A temporary 100% rating after surgery or a long hospital stay is a related but separate concept governed by its own regulations, so it is not the same as a staged schedular rating.

How Does the VA Choose the Dates for Each Stage?

This is where many disputes arise. The VA generally looks for the date the evidence first shows that the condition met the criteria for a particular percentage. Often, that date is tied to a specific medical record or examination.

The problem is that an exam date is not always the date the condition actually changed. A veteran may have reported worse symptoms to a treating provider months before the VA examination. If the treatment records document the same findings earlier, the higher rating may have been supported earlier too.

The One-Year Rule for Increases

For increased ratings, effective dates follow 38 C.F.R. § 3.400(o). The general rule is the date the VA received the claim or the date entitlement arose, whichever is later. There is an important exception under § 3.400(o)(2): the effective date can be the earliest date it is factually ascertainable that an increase in disability occurred, if the claim is received within one year from that date.

In practice, this indicates that medical evidence from the year before a claim for increase can matter. If records show the condition had already worsened during that window, the higher rating may reach back to when the worsening was documented, not just the date the claim was filed.

What Can This Look Like in Practice?

The following is a general illustration, not a prediction about any individual case.

A veteran’s service-connected back condition is rated 10%. They file for an increase after their pain and stiffness worsen. The VA schedules an exam eight months later, finds limited motion that meets the 20% criteria, and issues a decision assigning 10% from the claim date and 20% from the exam date.

Reviewing the claims file, the veteran finds physical therapy notes from shortly after the claim was filed. Those notes recorded range-of-motion measurements similar to what the VA examiner found months later. The therapy notes may support an argument that the 20% level was met earlier than the exam date.

In another version of the same situation, the veteran’s records from four months before the claim already show the same limited motion. Because the claim was filed within one year of that date, § 3.400(o)(2) may allow the increase to reach back to when the worsening was factually ascertainable.

Neither outcome is automatic. Each depends on whether the records are specific enough to meet the rating criteria at the earlier dates.

What Should Veterans Check When They See Staged Ratings?

A staged decision deserves the same careful review as any other rating decision, with extra attention to dates. Useful questions include:

  • What evidence did the VA rely on for each stage? The decision should explain why it chose each period.
  • Does the stage change line up with an exam date? If so, check whether earlier records show the same findings.
  • Were treatment records from the full period considered? Missing records can push a higher stage later than it should be.
  • Was a lower stage assigned after improvement? If so, confirm the improvement was real and lasting, not a single good day.
  • Do the percentages match the rating criteria? Compare the findings in each period with the criteria for the diagnostic code used.

Can Staged Ratings Be Challenged?

Yes. A veteran who disagrees with any stage, or with the dates separating the stages, can pursue the decision review options available after a VA decision. The right option depends on whether the issue is how the VA read the existing evidence or whether new evidence is needed to show an earlier change.

For example, if treatment records showing earlier worsening were already in the file but overlooked, the issue may be an error in the existing record. If those records were never submitted, new and relevant evidence may be required. Deadlines apply to each review option, so dates on the decision letter matter.

Why Staged Ratings Can Work in a Veteran’s Favor

Staged ratings are not only a source of disputes. They can also help. Without staging, the VA might assign a single lower rating for the entire period, even if the condition clearly worsened partway through. Staging allows the higher percentage to apply from the point the evidence supports it.

They can also capture periods of severe symptoms that later improved. A veteran whose condition was worse for a year before stabilizing may receive a higher rating for that year rather than a single lower rating for everything.

When Can a Lawyer Help?

Staged ratings depend heavily on dates, medical records, and how the VA applied the rating criteria in each period. Reviewing them often requires lining up treatment notes, exam reports, and the decision side by side.

A VA benefits lawyer can help veterans compare the evidence with the dates the VA chose and decide whether a review makes sense. Veterans in Utah looking for guidance may consider talking with VA claim attorneys about whether each stage of their rating reflects the record. VA attorneys for veterans and other lawyers for veterans benefits can also help identify which review option fits the specific issue.

About Southwest Law Firm

Veterans with questions about how their ratings were staged can call (623) 259-5959 to reach Southwest Law Firm, a Glendale, Arizona, practice that handles VA disability claims, ratings, and appeals for veterans nationwide. Attorney Jay Mendoza served in the Marine Corps, is accredited by the VA, and is admitted before the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims. Veterans planning a visit can pull up their location on Google Maps.

Share this entry
JC

About the writer

Jayden Collins

Jayden Collins is a seasoned wordsmith with a passion for crafting engaging and informative content across a wide range of topics. With years of experience in the realm of writing, Jayden has honed their skills to deliver articles and blogs that captivate and educate readers. Their expertise spans diverse subjects, from technology and science to lifestyle and culture.

Jayden's dedication to providing well-researched and insightful content shines through in every piece they produce. Armed with a keen eye for detail and a knack for storytelling, they excel in distilling complex information into easily digestible narratives that resonate with audiences of all backgrounds.

Whether unraveling the latest advancements in artificial intelligence or delving into the nuances of mindfulness practices, Jayden's writing is characterized by clarity, depth, and a commitment to delivering value to readers. With a finger on the pulse of contemporary issues and trends, Jayden Collins is a trusted voice in the realm of online content creation, enriching the digital landscape with their expertise and passion for writing.

View all 19,148 articles →